Follow EmergingSpaces on Twitter

Insight, news and opinions from Starcom MediaVest Group London.

Subscribe by RSS or by Email,
and follow us on Twitter.

Conceptualising and evaluating experiences with brands on Facebook

Steve Smith's picture

New research paper from SMG Research

This research paper I authored was published yesterday, in the International Journal of Market Research.

Contact me if you would like a summary or to find out more. I've included the abstract below:

Despite the growth in the number of brands with a presence on social media such as Facebook and YouTube, questions remain about how to conceptualise and measure people’s experiences with brands’ content on social media, and how to measure the value of people’s behaviour around such content to brands. By interrogating quantitative data garnered from 6,400 respondents we sent to Facebook pages belonging to 27 brands across six brand categories during June 2011, this paper presents an overview of how we designed two sets of metrics, and some of the findings from these metrics: (1) a series of ‘value of experience’ metrics based on the likelihood of people who claim to have had positive experiences with a brand’s content on Facebook to say they are likely to do different social media, purchase funnel and brand advocacy actions for that same brand; and (2) a series of ‘value of a fan’ metrics that measure the likelihood of people who say they are likely to do different social media actions on a brand’s page (such as post positive comments or share content) to say they are also likely to do different purchase funnel and advocacy actions for that brand.

Bringing together out of home and mobile

Steve Smith's picture

Starcom MediaVest London’s CEO, Stewart Easterbrook, took part in a panel at a MediaTel event this morning, ‘The union of out of home and mobile’

The research shows that out of home experiences that explicitly incorporate and leverage mobile are likely to increase purchase funnel actions, conversations across communities, and brand equity.

Over half of UK adults now own a smartphone, and around 86% of smartphone owners regularly go online via their phones (Ofcom 2013). This, together with the fact that out of home has the second highest monthly reach behind TV, means that 16% of adults report using their mobiles to search the web partly as a result of out of home ads in the last month (Outdoor Media Centre). Clearly, search and brand sites need to be mobile optimised.

Searches resulting from out of home can also result in purchases. Thirteen percent of adults have bought because influenced by OOH advertising in the last month (OMC). Brands should look to see how they can increase likelihood of purchase through search, for example by showing local stockists and local deals, and through couponing.

Bringing mobile and out of home together also provides an opportunity to engage higher value customers. Young, mobile, affluent, connected and urban individuals are most likely to buy because of out of home. Forty four percent of 16-24s report having made purchases because they have been influenced by out of home media (OMC).

However, mobile activities should not be just about enquiry and purchase. Brand owners need to look to see how they can extend brand experiences through mobile, for example by using mobile to continue a story started on out of home. A partnership between Bing and Jay-Z to promote his autobiography is a good example of how this can be done.

Emotion is one of the biggest drivers to brand funnel and further media actions, and brand owners need to create out of home and mobile content that are likely to have emotional impacts. Fifty six percent of adults have had a positive emotional response to an out of home ad in the last month, closely followed by TV (OMC). Recommendation is the most common action by these people, followed by increases in brand equity.

Brand owners should also use mobile and out of home to drive talk and social media conversations. Ten percent of adults share (online or offline) something about an OOH experience per month (OMC). According to our Community Igniter research, 18% of people use out of home as a media source for at least one of their conversations.

Until recently, out of home advertising has been off limits to mobile phone activities on the London Underground. However, opportunities to engage people at some popular underground stations are now opening up due to Virgin Media, Vodafone and O2 opening up Wi-Fi hotspots in them. These provide the chance to target and engage higher value people, but connecting needs to be simple and easy. As with other locations, content needs to be compelling and people need to be given relevant reasons to undertake further activities on mobile.

QR codes and near field communications have had a lot of coverage in the media. However, QR codes show little sign of success in most campaigns, and people are more likely to manually search on their phones instead, due to high barriers to using QR codes. More phones now have NFC chips, but they don’t have scale, there aren’t many opportunities for people to use them, and research shows that most people see no or only little value in them.

Instead of QR codes and NFC, brand owners need to look at simpler ways of engaging people. I really like the partnership between Boots pharmacy and Weetabix. Weetabix recently ran a TV ad that encouraged people to take a photo of the ad and then go into a Boots store to get a discount.

Some apps are available that can extend a brand experience such as Aurasma, through which people can download additional content when a person points it at an image, such as an out of home ad. However, it has a small user base and it is not always simple to use.

Google Now is an emerging technology. This tracks people to give them ‘the right information at the right time’. There may be opportunities around out of home, for example tracking people who pass posters for particular ads that can then be used for better targeting and tracking of subsequent online behaviours.

Why brands should embrace multi-screening

Steve Smith's picture

Nearly half of smartphone owners (48%) and well over three quarters of tablet owners (80%) regularly use their devices whilst watching TV (InMobile and Mobext 2012).

These figures are considerable and even worrying to some brand owners. Yet it is easy to forget that television viewers have always given themselves to different tasks whilst the television is on, from going out to the kitchen to make a cup of tea during the ad break, to talking on the phone or even grannies doing the knitting whilst watching Coronation Street.

Unlike these activities, additional screen behaviours provide brands with further opportunities to create engagements with people. One of these is around facilitating complementary behaviours. Just over one fifth (22%) of simultaneous usage is complementary to the TV content or ads being shown (Google 2012), and up to 40% of tweets in the UK during peak TV times are about TV (Second Sync/Twitter 2013).

Still, this one fifth of simultaneous usage leaves a considerable amount of multiple screen activities unrelated to content on the TV. Yet rather than seeing this as a threat to advertising brands, brand owners should grasp the opportunity to provide compelling reasons for these people to talk about them and undertake advocacy, enquiry and purchase behaviours.

To do this, brand owners need to understand and facilitate people’s motives for doing complementary activities. These include interacting with or influencing content, seeking additional information about content and ads, wanting to analyse content further, and connecting with other viewers (Google 2012).

In terms of enquiry, online search is an obvious activity. During September 2012, SMG, London, ran a TV ad for a client, that included a search based call to action. The following chart shows the spike in the search term during the ad. Interestingly, over half of all searches came from mobile.

multiscreen01.Png

Twitter is a key medium some people use for discussing content. By adding social elements to TV ads, brand owners are able to stimulate people to discuss ads online, steer conversations, and quantitatively measure interactions.

One of the key challenges Twitter throws up is around how likely is your content to lead to conversations? Twitter underscores the demand that brands and advertisers create relevant and meaningful TV content that people therefore want to talk about. For this reason, Twitter is one tool advertisers should use for gauging the currency of their content (caveats around Twitter users accepted). If you look at your TV content and think a Twitter hash tag isn’t justified, or if you use a hashtag that results in few uses, it is more likely that you need to rethink that content rather than rethink Twitter. Unfortunately however, when some brands have seen very little use of their hashtags on Twitter, they have either dismissed Twitter or said that it is only useful for particular brands or brand categories.

Another mistake is when brands have attached a Twitter hashtag to an ad almost as an afterthought, without really thinking about what they want to achieve. On the other hand, brands that have developed a strategy behind using Twitter are more likely to achieve success. For example, Audi has achieved high engagement through the hashtag #ProgressIs, which it has used in its ads since the Super Bowl 2011. By encouraging people to complete the slogan, it underlies the value of having a call to action that people find compelling.

multiscreen02.Png

Mercedes created deeper engagement by asking viewers to vote for the next stage of a TV ad storyline on Twitter. The brand saw a greater lift in brand metrics compared with a similar Mercedes ad that had no voting interaction – up to 44% higher (ITV and Essential Research 2012). Strategically placing the ad during X-Factor - in which people vote for contestants - drew upon people’s already existing frame of mind for participation in a social event.

multiscreen03.Png

An argument to come from some brands is that Twitter users don’t currently form part of their target market, and so they don’t use it. For example, average ages of premium car brand owners such as Audi and BMW are well over 40 years old, whereas Twitter users are on average much younger.

However, TV ads for considered brands such as cars are likely to be the first touch points for many Twitter users. With Twitter integrated into them, there is the chance that some people will start a longstanding relationship with a brand that will result in a purchase. Twitter integration into TV ads for such brands may also result in new aspirational fans who will become brand advocates. In such cases, it is important that brands use Twitter as one element in an ecology of touch points through which they continue to uncover the brand story.

For less considered brand categories such as food and household products, opportunities are most often around driving purchase. A soap powder brand’s sponsorship of The Only Way is Essex saw a higher purchase intent among people who tweeted about the show and who were exposed to the brand’s sponsored tweets, than people who were not exposed (ITV and Essential Research 2012).

Brands have also used TV ads to drive competitions on Twitter. During late March and into April, Argos ran a TV ad that was primarily about click and collect, but also incorporated a competition. People who used the hashtag #WinDadsCamera had a chance of winning a new camera.

multiscreen04.Png

Competitions such as these can be good at raising brand awareness. But although they may achieve headlines among marketers, they often do little to engage people in deeper interactions with the brand or to stimulate people to converse about it. In fact, our own social media research shows that running straightforward competitions like this is one of the lowest value actions a brand can do. A more engaging competition might have been for Argos to ask people to upload a badly taken photo to show why they need a new camera.

In summary, these are six recommendations about using Twitter on the back of TV ads:

  1. Use Twitter as a tool for gauging the currency of ad content to viewers
  2. Have a strongly developed strategy for integrating Twitter into TV ads. What do you want to achieve?
  3. Understand the characteristics and needs of your intended audience, and their motives for second screening
  4. Calls to action in ads should prompt conversations, interactions, or actions that require more involvement than mere re-tweeting
  5. Considered brands should see Twitter as an opportunity to engage people as part of a much longer purchase funnel than for less considered brands, and use Twitter help create aspirational brand advocates even among non-brand purchasers
  6. Use Twitter as one component among different media to tell connected brand stories

We originally wrote this article for Media Tel's Connected Consumer

Content Marketing - 2013 Trends

"Content Marketing is the only marketing left" - Seth Godin

Content Marketing has been a leading trend in our industry over the last few years and is set to get bigger and better in 2013. In a world where consumer behaviour is constantly changing and becoming more complex, a push advertising strategy that only relies on the presence of advertising messages at the right place and right time has it's limitations. We are increasingly seeing advertisers position brands as publishers by delivering content that engages consumers, generates dialogue and delivers immersive experiences. This is also the direction that SMG has taken as a Human Experience company as we understand the importance of content marketing with story telling and experiences at it's heart.

Mashable recently posted this interesting article on the top 10 trends in Content Marketing for 2013 which is worth a read.

The point about the "death of the microsite" really resonated with me because with hyper-curated personalised content available through platforms like Twitter, the whole idea of a microsite as a one stop destination for a brand's content is quite dated. So the old paradigm of "driving traffic" to a "hub" is fast dying out and we need to seek better, personalised and dynamic ways of engaging our consumers.

However, as a recent survey by Econsultancy points out, while 90% of marketers believe content marketing will become more important over the next 12 months, just 38% of companies have a content marketing strategy in place. Consequently, there are some basic considerations for a healthy content marketing strategy that should not be ignored.

1. Quality - Recognising that there is a crucial difference between "material" like videos, white papers, audio or video produced in isolation and "content" produced in line with a well thought through strategy that tells stories about the brand and delivers experiences that are valuable to the audience.

2. Cross-Media Approach - Recognising the various touchpoints for consumers and engage across them to deliver a seamless experience. In a world of multi-screening and augmented reality, the boundaries between traditional and new media have blurred and marketers who aren't thinking about their media strategy more holistically are missing a big opportunity.

3. Personalisation and Curation - Personalising experiences and content for the relevant target audiences is key to making experiences meaningful. Data is driving personalisation across digital media and should be a key element of a content-led marketing strategy.

4. Distribution - Ensuring that your content is findable by making SEO an important part of a content-led strategy. In addition, quality distribution channels that enable sharing should be identified.

5. Longevity - Thinking about the value of content beyond a set campaign period and work towards building an "always on strategy", so users come back to engage with your brand.

Of course, a content-led marketing strategy can be delivered effectively in many different ways, with different levels of investment and scale, but to be successful it needs to be well thought through.

On the one hand, there are big experience based ideas that are amplified through use of paid, owned and earned media channels. Felix Baumgartner's Red Bull Stratos jump is a good example of such an idea.

However, consumer engagement can also be achieved by delivering meaningful content to communities across small but trusted platforms. Our own More Th>n team did this with their partnership with MSN to promote the client's pet insurance product. They were able to engage the pet-owner community through providing quality content on pet health and well-being, thereby establishing themselves as an authority in a space where quality content was hard to find.

As the More Th>n example goes to show, marketers are increasingly relying on content, not just to create brand loyalty and change brand perceptions, but also to generate more direct response. Advertisers like O2, who have traditionally focused on acquisition based performance marketing are latching onto the importance of content marketing and their latest campaign with Microsoft is a step in the right direction.

http://www.msn-life-unlocked.co.uk/

As a Human Experience company, we are well positioned to deliver industry leading content ideas in 2013, so watch this space.

What can Tesco expect to achieve through its Clubcard TV trial?

Steve Smith's picture

A while ago, I wrote about how brands need to be generous to their customers. They need to give them something extra in order to reward and thank them. When brands do this, they are able to enhance or create:

Differentiation
Relevance
Equity
Admiration
Memory and thereby word of mouth

Fast forward to this month, and news is emerging that Tesco is trialing a free TV and film service for its Clubcard customers. The service is running through Blinkbox, the streaming service the supermarket bought an 80% share in back in 2011. It promises "no schedules, no fees and no fuss", and the site explains how Clubcard TV is a "thank you" to its customers.

clubcardtv.png

Mums’ use of the service means they will give Tesco a greater role in a central family routine – TV, thus building brand equity and brand meaning. Word of mouth is also likely to be one of the outcomes of Clubcard TV, meaning an uptake in applications for Clubcard and thereby footfall at its stores. Mums talking about the service will also mean that some lapsed Clubcard owners are likely to reignite their relationship with the supermarket.

Given the importance of word of mouth, it is important that Tesco identify, target and engage mums who are most likely to be influential within their personal communities and whose personal communities are sufficiently large to maximise coverage. My colleague Paul Selby demonstrated in an earlier post how supermarkets can reach such people through our experience planning application, Community Igniter.

ASDA's Christmas competitions lead to significant uplifts in Facebook engagement following TV ad launch

Steve Smith's picture

SMG's Social Media Behaviour Index shows that strong opportunities arise when brand owners integrate social media with their television experiences. Supermarkets had a chance to leverage these opportunities during November and December, by integrating their Christmas TV ads with Facebook - to use these ads to encourage people to visit their Facebook pages on which they could experience further content, post comments and – importantly – share that content.

To see the results of how well supermarkets leveraged from these opportunities, we did two things:

1) We calculated the average number of comments and shares per brand post during the seven days prior to the launch of each supermarket's Christmas TV ads.

2) We then did the same for the seven days following each launch, to observe any uplifts.

Results were very revealing. ASDA, Waitrose and Sainsbury’s all achieved higher average number of comments per post in the seven days following their TV ad launch. When it came to average number of shares, ASDA performed very well, with a six fold uplift over the week before its TV ad launch. Whilst Morrisons saw no change in comments, shares declined. Tesco's average number of shares declined significantly.

xmasposts.png

Why did ASDA perform so well? Competitions. One post was about winning £1,000 to spend at Christmas (2,456 comments and 524 shares). Another post was about winning £100 to spend on clothes ‘for the Christmas party’ (2,071 comments and 203 shares). A third post about giving away three special edition X-Box controllers achieved 863 shares. A post promoting the supermarket cutting 2p off a litre of petrol, achieved 2,420 shares. Impressively, ASDA achieved 90,000 likes against its content throughout the whole seven days post TV ad launch, compared with 39,000 the week before.

How TV programme content gets grocery retailers' highest value customers talking

Paul Selby's picture

What’s the role of branded content on television? Data from our Community Igniter explains, and shows how advertiser-funded programming (AFP) could be highly valuable for grocery retailers.

It’s a good time to explore research on this topic because despite upcoming initiatives from Sainsbury’s, supermarkets have arguably been slow to harness the potential of AFP. Sainsbury’s What’s Cooking airs soon on Channel 4; another example was Tesco’s Real Food Family Cook Off, but that was in 2011.

Community Igniter shows (Chart 1) that programming content is far more likely than ads or sponsorships to be referenced in conversations held by supermarkets’ customers about what to buy and where to buy it. We’re looking at all programming here (not specifically ad-funded) but the implications are clear: if supermarkets can successfully infuse the viewer’s programme experience with their brand experience using AFP they can deliver conversation starting TV.

tv influencing food conversations.JPG

Furthermore grocery retailers higher value food customers are particularly likely to refer to programme content.

Pinpointing people who spend £80+ on a weekly basis (Chart 2), not only are they more likely to regularly hold conversations about household food, recipes or choice of retailer (19% do, versus 16% of all Adults) but TV programming content is even more influential. The proportion saying conversations about choice of grocery retailer are informed by TV programmes, for example, rises to 40% for this group.

programming important for high value customers.JPG

Clearly there are implications for the value of AFP, and indeed product placement. Food and supermarket conversations are started and shaped by TV programmes – grocery retailers executing TV content strategies well can tap into this social currency.

Sainsbury's to make content a cornerstone of its marketing

Steve Smith's picture

Sainsbury's has announced it is going to put content at the heart of its marketing, and will merge its content and digital teams to deliver its strategy.

Especially pertinent is the remark by Sarah Warby (Sainsbury’s marketing director), that ‘If you are not feeling and acting like a publisher, you are missing a massive trick’*.

But what is the value of content to a brand? Facebook is an obvious opportunity for brands to publish a breadth of content, and Starcom MediaVest has an ongoing project to understand what brands can expect to achieve by it.

To date we have interrogated around forty brands on Facebook, and measured the likelihood of visitors to do a variety of social media actions (e.g. watch a video, comment or share that content) and brand actions (from enquiry through to purchase through to recommendation).

One of the most important findings is that supermarkets need to make content emotionally impactful. Across all the top five supermarkets we found that people who were impacted emotionally by supermarkets' Facebook content were most likely to do a social media or a purchase funnel action. 75% of people impacted emotionally were likely to prefer the supermarket over its competitors (compared with 23% of people who were not emotionally impacted). 58% were likely to talk about the supermarket (compared with 14% who were not emotionally impacted).

Despite this, there is significant room for improvement. Overall, 62% of visitors to supermarket Facebook pages say they were not impacted emotionally.

Another lesson we have learned is that supermarkets need to make sure that social media is integrated within other media channels. By making TV ads emotionally impactful, supermarkets can help encourage people to visit their social media to find out more and have deeper interactions with them.

For example, during the month prior to John Lewis releasing its celebrated Christmas snowman ad, we found that John Lewis achieved an average of 27 comments for each of its Facebook posts. During November - the month of its release - this more than doubled, to 69. Even more impressively, the average number of shares per post rose six fold, from 8 during October, to 49.

johnlewisfacebook.png

*Interview with Brand Republic (http://www.brandrepublic.com/news/1165763/)