Follow EmergingSpaces on Twitter

Insight, news and opinions from Starcom MediaVest Group London.

Subscribe by RSS or by Email,
and follow us on Twitter.

Post 'first screen / second screen'

Steve Smith's picture

You Tube’s announcement that is will be launching sixty channels of full programmes from across Europe was followed by a presentation on Wednesday by Robert Kyncl, YouTube head of content

In it, Kyncl dismissed the notion that smartphones and tablet devices are mere ‘second screens’ to the ‘first screen’ of the TV.

Instead, Kyncl argued that people would discover content on their mobiles, and then swipe that content to the television, making the television the ‘second screen’.

This is semantics. Instead, what are the actual meanings people attach to their televisions? In actual fact, people ‘swiping’ content to ‘dumb’ televisions isn’t anything new. People do very similar things when they watch DVDs, stream video from their games devices or use boxes such as YouView or Apple TV. For most people doing this, the TV is the device on which they continue to have deep and meaningful experiences and so continue to build deep and emotional attachments to it.

Nevertheless, Kyncl has a point. The frequency of people discovering content on their mobiles will increase, and with YouTube providing more long form content, people will want to view that content on their televisions and then use their mobiles for a variety of activities, from accessing complementary content and communicating about it, through to enquiry, exploration, online shopping and communicating about unrelated things.

This suggests that using the terms ‘first’ screen’ and ‘second’ screen’ are no longer sufficiently accurate to describe people’s behaviour. This is because these terms prioritise one device - whether it be the television or mobile - over another. Rather, my view is that the relationship people will create between TV and mobile will be characterised much more by mutual symbiosis, in which they give both devices equal importance and priority.

1 comment

Oli wrote 32 weeks 15 hours ago

Semantics indeed, a better way of thinking about 1st and 2nd screen is which one actually dominates the attention at the time.

1) 2nd screen as a supporting information source to TV's 1st- who is that actor, bit more info on what I am watching etc - films, news.
2) 2nd screen (mobile / tablet) is actually the 1st screen. TV is on but most of ones attention is on the smaller screen FB, Twitter, messaging etc. TV is the fuel driving the smaller screen, but main experience is on the interaction and experience of connecting. - X-Factor etc.
3) Augmenting the experience and the two working together - football as the prime example where 2nd screen gives you stats and info as things unfold on the tv.

Just a thought but one that has been brewing for a while.

Oli.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Add your comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

More information about formatting options